| Year |
Name(s) |
| 1911 |
Chester Orris |
| 1912 |
Clifford McDaniels |
| 1913 |
Clifford McDaniels |
| 1914 |
Clifford McDaniels |
| 1916 |
Ross Yockey |
| 1920 |
Ralph Reynolds |
| 1921 |
Emide Thomas |
| 1922 |
Al Dunn |
| 1923 |
Alex Della Valle |
| 1924 |
Stanley Berkman |
| 1925 |
Charles Schade |
| 1926 |
Edward Taylor |
| 1927 |
Harold Duff |
| 1928 |
Alex Graham |
| 1929 |
Harold Lutz |
| 1930 |
Henry Ott |
| 1931 |
Paul Miles, Carl Cataio |
| 1932 |
Anthony Cappezutti |
| 1933 |
Eugene Forker |
| 1934 |
George Stonis, Orville Freed |
| 1936 |
Henry Popko |
| 1937 |
Al Barnes |
| 1938 |
John Beckert, Ken Graham, Harry Schmidt |
| 1941 |
Chet Swick, Ray Banks |
| 1942 |
Tom Carey |
| 1945 |
Richared Barclay, Paul Lyons |
| 1946 |
Blair Hildebrand |
| 1947 |
Ray Nedwidek |
| 1948 |
Jack Schantz |
| 1949 |
Robert Phillips, Ray McCarthy |
| 1950 |
Paul Clawson, John Kracsun |
| 1951 |
John Kracsun |
| 1952 |
Lawrence Patchel |
| 1953 |
Richard Dilts, John Hyland |
| 1954 |
Don Goltz |
| 1955 |
Tom Heckendorn, Chuck Travers |
| 1956 |
Don Heald, Bob Probst |
| 1957 |
Dana Austin, Lou Cangelosi |
| 1958 |
Bill Halli, Will Barber |
| 1959 |
Tom Dolde, Hank Tomko |
| 1960 |
Bruno Raso, Gus Nauman |
| 1961 |
Quentin Currie, Gene Collodi |
| 1962 |
Denny Douds, Tony Nunes |
| 1964 |
Bill Kelly, Jim Mill |
| 1965 |
Frank Lucido, |
| 1966 |
John Miceli |
| 1967 |
George Nelepa, Denny Hyland |
| 1968 |
John Napotnick, Pat Dougherty |
| 1969 |
Steve Konick |
| 1970 |
Bob Basile, Dave Stilley |
| 1972 |
Mike Kish, Dan Toomey |
| 1973 |
Terry Factor, Curt Kral, Stan Stanchek, George Mihalik |
| 1974 |
Tom Yaksick, Tim Braun, Wally Robinson, Jeff Sieminowski |
| 1975 |
Jerry Skocik, Dave Tierney |
| 1976 |
Chuck Calo, Lew Sweitzer, Mike Milito, Don Schuetz |
| 1977 |
Brad Burton, Sam Debona |
| 1978 |
Bob Schrantz, John Martin, Chuck Miller, Sam Kiefer |
| 1979 |
Herb Allen, Doug Labor, Mike Venditti |
| 1980 |
Greg Hurda, Paul Baroffio |
| 1981 |
Ricky Porter, Gary Hunt, Tony Emanuele |
| 1982 |
Jack Muller, Tony Emanuele |
| 1983 |
Don Chrisitan, Jim Watts, Chuck Debor |
| 1984 |
Craig Bouslough, Gary Scholze |
| 1985 |
Wade Acker, Ed Robinson, Chuck Sanders |
| 1986 |
Eric Denton, Dave Linton |
| 1988 |
Rich Moskal, Todd Massack, Joe Mehaut |
| 1989 |
Tim Kelly, Steve Burket |
| 1990 |
Terry Jordan, Jeff Lang, Joe Dahlstrand |
| 1991 |
Terry Jordan, Rob Henne, Mark Booth, Tony Robinson |
| 1992 |
Mark Booth, Sonny Carson, Tony Robinson, John Sikora |
| 1993 |
Pete Geis, Jim Ward, John Oldham, Rahmon Hart, Greg Hopkins, Kareem Coles |
| 1994 |
LaMonte Coleman, Greg Hopkins, Sam James, Brian Woodring |
| 1995 |
Sam James, Mark Ferguson |
| 1996 |
Chad Vogt, Dave Meunch |
| 1997 |
John Curran, Shawn Rohrer |
| 1998 |
Nate Snyder, Rick Magulick |
| 1999 |
Brian Polk, Randy McKavish, Mike Welhorsky |
| 2000 |
Randy McKavish, Mike Waszczuk |
| 2002 |
Shawn Hanzely, Ryan McKavish, Chris Patrarca |
| 2003 |
Bill Ricks, Jesse Kelley |
| 2006 |
Jerome Whiting, Mike Butterworth |
| 2007 |
Mike Butterworth, Nate Crookshank, Clint Forsha, Jared Palmer |
| 2010 |
Brandon Fusco, Aaron Nall |
| 2011 |
AJ Hopp, Chad Noce, Jayson Nickson, Akeem Satterfield, Zach Sheridan |
| 2012 |
Austin Fedell, Akeem Satterfield, Jeff Thompson |
| 2013 |
Quindell Dean, John Schademan, Gary Allen |
| 2014 |
Teddy Blakeman, Kirk Nypaver, Isiah Coleman |
| 2015 |
Cory Tucker, Mike Grata, Brett Crenshaw |
| 2016 |
Shamar Greene, Joe LoSchiavo, Bob Vernick, Derrick Fulmore, Joe Phillips |
| 2017 |
Marcus Martin, Milly Raye, Ian Park, Delmar Henderson |
| 2018 |
Andrew Koester, Tavarus Sample, Wes Hills, Steve Gaviglia, Kyle Hall |
| 2019 |
Roland Rivers III, Tim Vernick, Jermaine Wynn Jr., Brad Zaffram |
| 2021 |
Henry Litwin, Austin Wayt, Tim Vernick, Chad Kuhn |
| 2022 |
Noah Grover, Colton Rossi, Jeff Marx, Selvin Haynes, D.J. Adediwura, Kevin Hyde |
| 2023 |
Munchie Johnson, Kyle Kudla, Kyle Sheets, Kam Kruzelyak, Brayden Long, Nick Stazer |
| 2024 |
Munchie Johnson, Kam Kruzelyak, Brayden Long, Eddie Faulkner IV, Josh Stokes, Josh George |
| 2025 |
Joe Cooper, Michael Henwood, Jacob Snow, Anthony Vespo |
